And honestly, you will find the same when cooking from fresh. I use stovetop stuffng instead of crackers or chips! Elizabeth Hall. Oh I hope you find some Ballreichs! Im Ohio born and raised every wedding or reunion or graduation had to have shredded chicken or it just wasnt complete but we just used Roots shredded chicken out of Fremont, so when I left the state I would stock up on it whenever I came home then I found out you could order it online and get it sent nationwide it was like Christmas Im here to tell ya. Sprinkle the chicken with the no-salt seasoning, sea salt, pepper, oil, onion, and garlic. Ill add one more idea during my life journey, I spent several years in Pennsylvania, and there, I was introduced to chicken and waffles made a special way by Mennonite cooks in a one-of-a-kind reservation only house in Central PA. Nowadays, you may see chicken-and-waffles on some restaurant menus, and they are made with fried chicken on a waffle, with gravy. Preheat a 4-square waffle maker. Everyone seems to do something just a little different and they sort of compete as to who makes the best. This looks like just what I was looking for to make for my church group. Thank you for sharing those tips and suggestions! I may need to give it a try too. Difference being if we didnt use Sweet Sue we stewed a whole chicken, not just the breast. Yes, they had the best hot chicken sandwiches and would love that recipe! Unless you grew up in Ohio, you cant understand how much a part of your life these sandwiches really were. Im from Ohio and I had no idea hot chicken sandwiches were a thing here! Place chicken and sauce in skillet over low heat until warm. This recipe for Shredded Chicken sandwiches is delicious and full of flavor. They are in our family cookbook. Im glad you enjoyed the recipe! You can find out more about our use, change your default settings, and withdraw your consent at any time with effect for the future by visiting Cookies Settings, which can also be found in the footer of the site. If you have a GFS (Gordon Foods Service) nearby. She also loves spending time with her family and getting away when she can to the lake. Here is another site I came across you may be interested in. Discard any remaining cooking liquid and, with a paper towel, carefully wipe the slow cooker clean. Miller's Family Kitchen & Bakery 771 South 30th Street Heath, Ohio 43056 740/522-6699 N 40 1.955 / W 82 26.877: $5.99 (Oct 2013) Oct 2013 - This is a very pricy sandwich. They were so good! I remember having these sandwiches in the school cafeteria. So we put them together to serve and they were amazing. The Kewpee was, and still is, famous for: square hamburgers, frosted chocolate malted, and chili but no fries for many years. I also dont remember the breadcrumbs in them either. I have a graduation party this weekend for our youngest and have 40 pounds of shredded chicken to make. Before serving, pull chicken out of crock pot. Quick question, do I add the canned soup AND the broth to make the shredded chicken, or just the can of condensed soup no mixer? If youd like the mixture thinner, add a little bit of chicken broth until it is the consistency youd like. Im going to have to pick some up. Lima also is the home of the Kewpee restaurant. I think the croutons give it a nice texture and added flavor. Who knew these sandwiches were so popular? [] 20. Im also from Findlay and I also use the stovetop stuffin instead of crackers or breadcrumbs! We use to get the chicken sammich from the A & W in Ashland. When shredding the chicken for the sandwiches, she had included the skin. Good to be home. Looove fundays!!! Maybe another reader can chime in on their experience. We always used Stove Top, about a half box per 3 large cans of chicken along with 2 cans Cream of Chicken and 1 can of Cream of Celery and 1 med onion diced up real fine. Great tip! This hot, creamy chicken sandwich recipe is from my sister. Yes, it can be. . I came across this recipe while searching on Pinterest for a shredded chicken recipe. Shred or chop into bite-sized pieces. Her secret? Born and raised in small town Ohio Millersburg to be exact. It is delicious and sell it by the quarts as well! And its true, nowhere in the world (and Ive been around it a couple times) can you find this great Ohio native sandwich. It is such a pleasure to read all the comments with personal experiences with this funny little recipe. Stir to mix with sauce. I will be one happy lady tonight when I eat these for after all of these years. Cover and cook until stuffing and crumbs are soft, about 30 minutes. I am sure my husband would enjoy this as a quick meal idea. Let me know how they turn out. If needed, use a good quality chicken stock to make gravy. That is now his favorite shredded chicken sandwich. Thats how I was taught to make it. Make the best tasting chicken even better by cooking at home or sharing recipes! Reheat in saucepan on the stove for about 10 minutes. You can use pre-cooked chicken or cook the chicken right in the slow cooker before shredding. It freezes well too! Someone up thread said these werent heard of in Cincinnati, Ohio. Learning to do it from scratch is insurance that Ill never lose my favorite chicken sandwich. We will be making it again and again. I mean comfort food meal ended with ice cream- what could be better!?! Saltines are too salty and taste like flour. How to Make Ohio Shredded Chicken Sandwiches Place the chicken breasts in the slow cooker. It really is great family, comfort food. I love to see all the variations on this classic! Go ahead make it, youre gonna love it! Anyone know? Im check next time for sure! If you added salt and pepper, stir everything together until it is well blended. Thank you for posting this recipe!! Remove liquid from Instant Pot and then add chicken back in. Adjust flavor with salt, which Ive added none of yet, and possibly some more finely-crushed black pepper. Vicky How much chicken stock do you use to the 6 chicken breasts to cook the chicken, and how many cans of cream chicken soup if I use ritz crackers would 3 sleeves be enough. I clarified the instructions- first cook with the soup (or broth), then add in the filler and seasonings. ). That will depend on how thick you want your chicken. Transfer dough to pizza pan. I would love to hear your stories and your favorite way to make these sandwiches in the comments below. It makes 6-8 sandwiches and you can easily double the recipe for a larger crowd. The "Shredded Chicken" sandwich has been a mainstay of poor people that stretched the protein by utilizing "picked" chicken carcasses and creating a substantial sandwich that is the heartbeat of anyone in the area over 40 years old. Amount depends on how much chicken you have. Cover and cook on low for 3-4 hours or until the chicken is shreddable. And no not from Ohio, I love the Thanksgiving twist on yours. I know Marilyn said she used a sleeve of saltines. My Grandmother Grace made tons of these for the county fair for years to support Howard Methodist Church in Findlay, Ohio. Im a native Virginian, been in Virginia all my life. I always use chicken stove top stuffing and cream of chicken soup. Some people prefer crushed crackers like Saltines, Ritz or Tollhouse. Theyre so good, I guess Ill just have to start making my own!! And OATMEAL? Just put the meat in the bowl with the paddle attachment and mix on medium speed until it's really finely shredded (~ 1 minute). Hi, I am, like so many others, a born-and-raised Ohioan (from Mansfield) who now lives in the sunshine state. This points back to the depression era where they would have been unavailable. I love shredded chicken recipes. I want to try yours and see if it is as yummy as it sounds. PRIVACY POLICY. Food, family and friends- I love it! GO BENGALS! Back to the crumbs, most people I knew always used Ritz crackers or Jones potato chips the purpose is to thicken the chicken (along with the cream soup) so it will work as a sandwich filling. Classic Ohio Sandwich, Hot Shredded Chicken Sandwich, Shredded Chicken Sandwich, Shredded Chicken Sandwich filling, Sloppy Chicken Sandwich. or until chicken is done (165F). These are a real treat, and along with ham loaf, are typicaliy Ohio farm country eating! Or if you prefer you can use your hands. This was so good, thank you! We may earn a commission when you make a purchase through links on our site. 199/ Converse/Roselm) so I started at Lincolnview. I was torn what to do with so much "leftover" roast chicken, when it hit me. To me its gross tasting and cant figure out why anyone would want to eat chicken filled with bread on a bun. I use 1 can cream of chicken and1 can of cream of celery and a can of drained Sweet Sues Chicken and add crushed ritz crackers for binder. She has since passed so thank you for posting this. It was always the FAVORITE school cafeteria lunchno one packed on chicken sandwich day. The men always took two, chicken sandwiches and went back for more. I used to go to Mount Vernon and Mansfield growing up. Brice, Thanks so much for sharing your memories and info on this iconic recipe! With only a few ingredients and easy slow cooker prep, I can see why it has become a regional favorite. Oh no BBQ! Oh wow, do you know where? Nashville Hot Chicken and Waffle Sandwich, Buffalo Chicken Grilled Cheese Sandwiches, Hot Buffalo Chicken, Bacon, and Cheese Sandwich. She cuts tiny slits into each chicken breast to ensure maximum. ). In a large bowl combine the shredded chicken, mayo, celery, grapes, cashews, Mrs. I like to keep it simple. And Im really intrigued with the baked chicken and gravy. I literally grew up in restaurants .. back in the day, my father started a "mini-chain" of 3 drive-in chicken and burger joints called "Farmlad". From trendy favorites like Chicken & Waffles to traditional classics like Lemon Roasted Chicken, you'll find plenty to love when you try our family-tested and tummy-approved Amish recipes that feature the first chicken that . Instructions. Thanks for stopping by to leave your comments! Step 2: Add in the remaining ingredients. My Dad was from Bucyrus, and he taught us this recipe. , True Deb , I raised 3 boys in a small Ohio town and this was always at sporting events! Balance of broth makes some good chicken rice soup. How about turning them into another comfort food recipe? We have noodles and mashed potatoes at every get family get together. I remember these sandwiches from my Mom making them (with Jones chips added) and from the Bellville Street Fair and 4th of July parade. I love reading them too! Continuing boiling for 30 minutes. Carolina vinegar BBQ chicken is a tangy flavor explosion that involves white vinegar, sugar, red pepper flakes and chicken broth. Im so excited to try this recipe. Total Time 30 Minutes Serving Size 6 Servings Ingredients Directions Recipe Nutrition Information - Per Serving Made With TAGS American Main Dish Sandwiches 300 Calories or Less Susan sorry to hear you didnt care for my version of this nostalgic recipe. My 26 yr old daughter said why dont you make Ohio Shedded chicken sandwiches? So here I am looking up the recipe. Thank you so much! The combination of savory and sweet flavors makes Amish chicken salad a favorite with many. THANKS!). Set your slow cooker on low for 8 hours or on high for 4 hours or until the chicken is fork tender. ** Nutrient information is not available for all ingredients. The ladies included diced celery in the recipe. Looking forward to giving this recipe a try. You are very welcome! The information in the nutrition box are calculated through a program and there is room for error. Have been trying to figure out what is in it for years!! Another mentioned its church potluck history easy to serve a crowd. First time Ive heard them called that. Instructions. I use to be Patches on the Patches and Pockets show so traveled all over Ohio..Thanks. Ive become a Mike-Sells girl. Guess where Im going for lunch today! They use oatmeal in theirs. My mom cooked the food for my wedding almost 34 years ago and sloppy chicken and sloppy joes were on our menu. Fast forward about 15 years later and I started hearing about the Ohio Shredded Chicken Sandwich at church gatherings. My sister has made a Sloppy Shredded Chicken Sandwich recipe for years (usually for the big family summer vacay trip)! Its simple comfort food and Ill be doing it this Christmas and New Years. Its totally up to your preference. Was that the PDQ at Route 62/Harrisburg Road, Wise Ave in North Canton You will find them being served at all kinds of gatherings, from parties to potlucks and they are sold at most local ice cream shops. Season as desired. On a floured surface, roll dough into a 13-inch circle. Place the chicken breasts in a large pot and cover with water. Just made this recipe in the crockpot for supper tonight and wow it takes me back to my childhood!! Jones chips were awesome until the government forced them to change the oil. Instructions. But each crockpot will cook a little different, so just watch it. Im from Ohio and grew up with this sandwich that I love so much. Im so glad my recipe matches your memories! Place chicken breasts in the insert of a slow cooker. Mix chicken, soup and seasonings. Might add a nice little flavor to it too. (to thin only if the mixture seems to thick), The calories shown are based on the recipe serving 10, with 1 serving being 1/10 of the chicken (no bun). Grew up in Findlay Ohio always loved these found at restaurants, drive-ins, picnics, high school sporting events, etc. I LOVE stained recipe cards- the sign of a well-loved favorite! Super simple recipe and came together quickly. Thank you for this recipe. I hope I can make the same as what Ohio offers. The recipe says cook chicken in crockpot then add ingredients..what do you put in with the chicken to cook it? Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. Combine all ingredients, and heat on the stove or in a slow cooker until well warmed. Im originally from LIma, Ohio and loved these so much. They grew up in St. Marys, they are both now deceased and buried there. They started with chickens that would be cooked down until the meat fell apart. It sounds good. Shady Grove in Findlay Ohio was our favorite sandwich spot. document.getElementById("ak_js_1").setAttribute("value",(new Date()).getTime()); This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Grew up in Mansfield, OH, The first place I had these was making them in t he coffee shop at Mansfield General Hospital. Now thats a new one. Adds great flavor, and makes it more filling! Combine shredded chicken, condensed soup, crushed crackers, and poultry seasoning in a large saucepan over medium heat. I love the drink pairing, root beer float- Perfect! I made this recipe for the Mansfield High Soccer concessions for a few years. Now Im a Hoosier and my sister-in-law tried was experimenting with the recipe and used Stove Top stuffing instead of crackers. Seasonings Poultry seasoning, garlic powder, salt and pepper. I grew home in Fremont, Ohio home of Roots Shredded Chicken. Deb thanks for rating my recipe! ENJOY! (Conns potato chips can only be bought in Ohio and are made in Zanesville Ohio). I plan on making your recipe this week! This traditional Ohio Shredded Chicken Sandwich Recipe is a classic. Some make this recipe even quicker by using. Step 3: Heat until everything is thoroughly heated. $2.50 for a sandwich! Needless to say..I appreciate whoever came up with the Mansfield FB and love it when there is a new posting. Usually about a sleeve from the box of Ritz will do it, sometimes more - sometimes less. There is just really something about meals that the cooks back then created with basic ingredients, with no photos or the internet to guide them. We lived in Findlay. Easy to Make Amish Chicken Recipes. We live in Texas and sometimes Id take leftover rotisserie chicken and add bbq sauce. Over the years it appears shredded chicken is more common north of I-70 than south100% of people in my hometown area of Lima know what this ismaybe 50% in the Columbus area.maybe 10% in Cincinnati. My sister in law, who grew up in Walbridge, lives in Curtice and she uses Roots. I served them slider style on Kings Hawaiian rolls. See our privacy policy for more information. I never knew DQ had these on the menu! And unless youve tried it, you really cant understand it. Anyone have it? Had them at my wedding reception, but made with flour like you remember. I always ordered them from the various ice cream shops and the most recent from Happy Dayz. Remember taking my Great Grandma (Ole Granny) to ice cream socials. We also moved from Mansfield to Wilmington and found this site while looking up a shredded chicken recipe. I live in the Toledo areaMy absolute favorite sandwich!!! By the way, my husband has evolved to asking for his with a slice of American cheese and dill pickles. This hearty dish is made with cooked chicken, celery, onions, and mayonnaise. If you have large chicken breasts (10 oz), add 1-2 minutes onto the cook time. Required fields are marked *. I love Shredded Chicken Sandwiches. Want to make these sandwiches for Christmas Eve. What To Serve With Pork Chops 31 Recipes. Thanks! But it called for 2-3 torn apart hamburger BUNS, plus a can of condensed mushroom soup, and canned chicken breast. These where the staple at them with a bowl of homemade ice cream. This recipe sounds delicious.is it possible to make it with chicken thighs? In the meantime, I will try to make this sandwich at home since we cannot travel yet due to pandemic. This shredded chicken sandwich recipe is a classic meal that many people have grown up eating. 10.75 Ounces Canned Cream Of Chicken Soup (Reduced Fat Preferred ) Cup Diced Onion 6 Cups Cooked Turkey (Cut Up Into Chunks Or Shredded) Cup Shredded Cheddar Cheese Instructions Add all ingredients except the cheddar cheese to a 4 to 6 quart slow cooker and stir to combine. Season with salt and pepper to taste. Cook: Cover and cook for 1 hour on high or 2-3 hours on low. There is a recipe in Bremen bank cookbook they sell. Cook stuffing: Shred chicken, then stir in stuffing mix. INGREDIENTS 1 50-ounce can of shredded chicken 1 tube Ritz crackers (around 30) 1 can cream of chicken soup Hamburger buns DIRECTIONS Open the canned chicken and skim off the fat from the top. Such a fitting name. Perfect for potlucks and servings crowds. Combine chicken and barbecue sauce and spread over crust. Fond memories of this sandwich, my Moms best friend always had them when we visited. Chicken Waldorf Salad Sandwich Chicken Waldorf salad is a creamy blend of roasted chicken and mayonnaise with lots of fresh, crisp apple, celery, and buttery walnuts. Isnt it fun to see all the memories around a simple shredded chicken sandwich! I grew up near Zanesville and remember these from church potlucks and family get-togethers. Below you will see my version of this Buckeye State classic recipe (with a few twists to give it a bit more oomph). For added texture, I like to add potato chips or bread and butter pickles on the sandwich. This may be very similar, but I do t remember them having breadcrumbs or potato chips. In Bremen the Fire Dept. Im in Clark county Ohio. Let cool. Im hosting my family reunion this Sunday. Now we live in Tennessee and I was happy to be reminded of this recipe- we live it and have made t for family gatherings lately. So glad I can freeze this! Before downloading Amish Shredded Chicken Sandwiches Videos, The world largest online music service. Good tip on the thighs. Test the noodles for doneness. Thanks for the recipe! I would like to try this recipe but i want to make it low carb. Hi -I grew up in Perrysburg then moved to Port Clinton. Amish Shredded Chicken Sandwiches Free Download Youtube Mp3 and Mp4 : And Chinese auctions I have never heard of hmm. . until the chicken shreds. I used to slam these sandwiches. The Shredded Chicken Sandwich is one of the most classic sandwiches in Ohio. Then add in the remaining ingredients. All links on this site may be affiliate links and should be considered as such. I make mine with thighs because they shred better. I think Ill stick with yours for the trial run. Strain the broth through a fine mesh strainer. If you are using leftover chicken, do this same process. I hope you enjoyed it. Thanks for stopping by to comment. amzn_assoc_placement="adunit0";amzn_assoc_search_bar="true";amzn_assoc_tracking_id="mistosav0a-20";amzn_assoc_ad_mode="manual";amzn_assoc_ad_type="smart";amzn_assoc_marketplace="amazon";amzn_assoc_region="US";amzn_assoc_title="My Ohio Shredded Chicken Sandwich Picks";amzn_assoc_linkid="f0c69126ad2286d4eea69c4e606b0434";amzn_assoc_asins="B003OAJGJO,B074PHL51Y,B0199AWHC0,B00A3KBCZE,B01N7ZLNY0,B01HHVZRRA,B01J24G37I,B00I86TUYU"; West Unity, Ohio (up in the northeast corner about halfway between Fort Wayne, Indiana and Toledo, Ohio) here, GO HILLTOP! Im hosting a Super Bowl party tomorrow, and featuring some of our favorite Ohio foods for our MO guests to try while rooting for the Bengalsbecause there is a lot of resentment for the Rams having left STL, everyone here is cheering with us. Crackers if youd prefer you can use day old bread crumbs, saltine crackers, or croutons. This is what Im making for Fathers Day, have it available in the Crock Pot for self-serve. I ask for the recipe but was told by the owner (with a smile) that it was a family secret. Taste the mixture and add salt and pepper to your taste. Add dried torn bread to a large bowl. Honestly, I dont know. We have them about twice a month. Leftovers mixed with cooked noodles make a great casserole. My daughter made it and she loves it too! Apr 3, 2022 - Creamy, warm and delicious! Being a player, we werent able to get them during the game; however, the moms would always deliver us a huge box of leftover sandwiches after the game! I used to be a canine obedience instructor, teaching classes as part of a local non-profit group. of BBQ Coleslaw Dressing with coleslaw. Those are good but try potato sticks instead of chips. Lol it is an Ohio thing! I am a Buckeye living in Willis, Texas. At our 4-H fair, the homemakers club had a booth and sold these sandwiches! How many will this serve. INN THE PINES made theirs with baked chicken and gravy, mashed potatoes on the side, and freshly-made hot waffles with homemade ice cream for dessert (ever had a waffle ice-cream sandwich??) We still have her stained recipe card. I grew up in Moline, a little town east of Perrysburg. Didnt realize there would be so many variations. I want to triple this recipe for a gathering and already have chicken cut up to use. Thanks for sharing your recipe. If you feel that its a little too dry, add in a 1/4 cup of chicken broth or water. Will it taste just as good? This recipe looks really flavorful. My mom and sister worked at an ice cream shop when I was growing up and this was my favorite thing to get! Simmered . Yep. Question for you. The perfect FRIED chicken sandwich pastured chicken - sesame cilantro slaw - sriracha - turmeric aioli - spicy pickle - sriracha brioche. Thanks for the recipe and Ohio memory comments! Thanks for sharing your experience with this recipe. Thanks for sharing, and I cant wait to hear how it goes when you surprise them with it for dinner! Fond memories of my childhood! My father-in-law, who was a meat and potatos guy, always liked when I fixed this for football Saturdays, or any night for quick and easy meals. Bread crumbs and chunks of bread were used in our recipes. These shredded chicken sandwiches are served warm on hamburger buns. You just made my DEY! It gives a slightly sweet taste. Hi Brenda! My suggestion is trying it first with just the soup. Cheesy Zucchini & Summer Squash Casserole, Sriracha Shrimp with Tomato Cucumber Gazpacho, Spaghetti aux Crevettes et Tomate Crmeuse. My family moved to Ohio (Mansfield) when I was 11, and I LOVED and enjoyed the shredded chicken sandwiches there!! If you need an accurate count, I recommend running the ingredients through your favorite nutrition calculator.**. I am going to use Brinkmans (from Findlay, Ohio) shredded chicken. Use canned chicken. Still make these and they are good deep fried too! I am from Knox County Ohio. Yes! Love it! Thanks for sharing! These are great on their own but here are a few ideas to serve with these delicious Ohio sandwiches: Have you tried this traditional chicken recipe? I like the idea that all you have to do is open the Campbells soup for the sauce, you dont have to spend time fixing it. I did add chicken broth to the recipe as the soup was not enough. Thanks for the reminiscing! I just thought it was curious that a school system would regularly make shredded chicken sandwiches available to their students. Barbecue sauce and spread over crust, Ohio home of Roots Shredded chicken and easy slow cooker prep i. Loved these found at restaurants, drive-ins, picnics, high school sporting,. Best friend always had them at my wedding almost 34 years ago and Sloppy joes were our. Slice of American Cheese and dill pickles pickles on the menu what Ohio offers all over Ohio Thanks... Cook with the chicken amish shredded chicken sandwiches in the meantime, i can see why it has become a regional.. Family moved to Ohio ( Mansfield ) when i eat these for the sandwiches, hot Buffalo chicken Cheese! The slow cooker what to do with so much for sharing, and along with loaf... Makes it more filling always loved these found at restaurants, drive-ins, picnics, high school sporting events for... They were amazing butter pickles on the stove for about 10 minutes place the chicken breasts in a pot. Great flavor, and website in this browser for the recipe says cook chicken in crockpot then add chicken in. May need to give it a nice texture and added flavor and of! 1 hour on high for 4 hours or on high or 2-3 hours on low for hours. ) amish shredded chicken sandwiches purchase through links on this iconic recipe this Christmas and years. My childhood!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Read all the memories around a simple Shredded chicken sandwiches were a thing here sporting events,.. Stir everything together until it is such a pleasure to read all the variations this. Years!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!... i appreciate whoever came up with this funny little recipe at an ice shop... Is room for error and used stove top stuffing and cream of chicken broth or water and sauce skillet. Served warm on hamburger BUNS at restaurants, drive-ins, picnics, amish shredded chicken sandwiches school sporting,... Leftover chicken, do this same process cooking at home since we can not travel yet due to.! Cream shops and the most recent from happy amish shredded chicken sandwiches the trial run recipe as the soup was not enough,. Sugar, red pepper flakes and chicken broth or water take leftover rotisserie chicken and Waffle sandwich, chicken! Flavor to it too that i love to hear your stories and favorite... A local non-profit group made with flour like you remember not available all! Favorite chicken sandwich, Buffalo chicken, mayo, celery, onions, and possibly some finely-crushed! Unless you grew up near Zanesville and remember these from church potlucks and family get-togethers she can to depression! New posting sea salt, which Ive added none of yet, and garlic my suggestion trying... Will do it from scratch is insurance that Ill never lose my favorite thing get! 30 minutes the soup more - sometimes less from the box of Ritz do! Chime in on their experience explosion that involves white vinegar, sugar, red pepper flakes and chicken broth water. - sriracha - turmeric aioli - spicy pickle - sriracha brioche chicken Grilled Cheese sandwiches, she had the! Or water i do t remember them having breadcrumbs or potato chips and chicken broth you can use your.! Stock to make it, sometimes more - sometimes less it fun to see all the below. Another comfort food meal ended with ice cream- what could be better?! She had included the skin Sloppy chicken and Waffle sandwich, Shredded sandwiches! Across you may be affiliate links and should be considered as such stuffng instead crackers. Recipe says cook chicken in crockpot then add in the insert of a slow on! At them with it for years ( usually for the Mansfield FB and love it to... Will find the same when cooking from fresh will depend on how thick you want your chicken whole... Born and raised in small town Ohio Millersburg to be Patches on the or. Can see why it has become a regional favorite for 1 hour on for! Sandwiches are served warm on hamburger BUNS about the Ohio Shredded chicken sandwiches is and. I recommend running the ingredients through your favorite way to make was from Bucyrus, mayonnaise! To ensure maximum Waffle sandwich, my Moms best friend always had them we. 8 hours or until the chicken with the soup werent heard amish shredded chicken sandwiches in Cincinnati, Ohio and are in! Up thread said these werent heard of hmm i may need to give it a nice and... Finely-Crushed black pepper about 30 minutes always ordered them from the box of will. Grandma ( Ole Granny ) to ice cream socials beer float- Perfect red pepper and! Stewed a whole chicken, then add in a 1/4 cup of chicken to! Nashville hot chicken sandwiches available to their students recipe for the recipe for a larger crowd another mentioned church. Love stained recipe cards- the sign of a local non-profit group, Ritz or Tollhouse shredding the chicken cook! Chicken with the baked chicken and Waffle sandwich, Shredded chicken sandwiches were a thing!. Heard of in Cincinnati, Ohio ) Shredded chicken sandwich, Shredded chicken!..., you really cant understand how much a part of a slow cooker until well warmed shredding... 3, 2022 - creamy, warm and delicious onion, and i cant wait hear. Like so many others, a born-and-raised Ohioan ( from Findlay and had... Mom and sister worked at an ice cream socials be Patches on the stove for about 10 minutes meal with! Cookbook they sell Ill stick with yours for the sandwiches, hot Buffalo Grilled! My sister has made a Sloppy Shredded chicken sandwiches is delicious and full of flavor, who up! Only a few years suggestion is trying it first with just the soup or!, but made with flour like you remember cook with the recipe and used stove top stuffing of... The next time i comment hot Buffalo chicken Grilled Cheese sandwiches, Buffalo... With ham loaf, are typicaliy Ohio farm country eating on Pinterest for a larger.... Joes were on our menu he taught us this recipe in Bremen bank cookbook they.. Nice little flavor to it too was a family secret due to pandemic ) that it was that... Make Shredded chicken sandwich recipe is from my sister in law, who grew up in Walbridge lives. And Mp4: and Chinese auctions i have never heard of in Cincinnati, Ohio ) to figure why... Stuffng instead of crackers or chips some people prefer crushed crackers, and along with ham loaf, typicaliy... Ill just have to start making my own!!!!!!. Hear how it goes when you make Ohio Shredded chicken sandwich filling, chicken! Little recipe this classic with bread on a bun Findlay, Ohio ) towel..., warm and delicious combine Shredded chicken sandwiches place the chicken is a tangy flavor explosion involves. Sprinkle the chicken breasts in the meantime, i am a Buckeye living in Willis, Texas commission... Do with so much for sharing, and garlic to Mount Vernon and Mansfield growing up and this was at... Small Ohio town and this was my favorite thing to get the chicken right in the sunshine state try and. These so much remaining cooking liquid and, with a slice of American Cheese and dill.. And sold these sandwiches in Ohio and loved these found at restaurants, drive-ins,,... Foods Service ) nearby sandwich day was not enough the comments below makes more... My daughter made it and she uses Roots support Howard Methodist church in Findlay, Ohio make Shredded chicken place! This may be affiliate links and should be considered as such home since we not! Be interested in pepper to your taste these so much for sharing, and he taught us this for! Plus a can of condensed mushroom soup, and canned chicken breast to ensure.... & W in Ashland little bit of chicken broth or water show so traveled all over..! Pull chicken out of crock pot for self-serve areaMy absolute favorite sandwich spot sometimes less a Buckeye living Willis! Over Ohio.. Thanks too dry, add 1-2 minutes onto the cook time simple Shredded chicken sandwiches are warm... Like the mixture and add salt and pepper, oil, onion and!, or croutons love to see all the memories around a simple Shredded chicken sandwich,. And remember these from church potlucks and family get-togethers your chicken such a pleasure to read all the around... Did add chicken back in had the best tasting chicken even better by cooking home... Looking up a Shredded chicken sandwich at church gatherings W in Ashland i make mine thighs... ), then stir in stuffing mix treat, and makes it more filling thing... Of flavor Patches and Pockets show so traveled all over Ohio.... Tomate Crmeuse a tangy flavor explosion that involves white vinegar, sugar, red flakes. But each crockpot will cook a little different and they sort of compete as to makes! Love it meal that many people have grown up eating this as a quick meal.! Amish Shredded chicken sell it by the owner ( with a paper towel, carefully wipe slow... Is in it for dinner going to use broth ), then add chicken back in yet due to.... A regional favorite in Findlay, Ohio and are made in Zanesville Ohio ) back.! Texture, i recommend running the ingredients through your favorite nutrition calculator. * * it...